I talk to the trees

Today’s post is from our wonderful Power of Moms author Catherine Arveseth.

When I was young, my Dad would sing this little tune — usually to the background of six kids banging utensils, crashing toys, yelling and chasing each other around the house while one of us wheeled through the kitchen on roller skates. (That isn’t an exact scenario, but you get the idea.)

It went like this:

“I talk to the treeeees … but they don’t listen to me.”

I thought it was just one of his nonsense songs; he had a bunch of them. But as I grew older, I realized he was singing about us. That sing-songy phrase was his way of coping with a crowd of rowdy kids who weren’t listening, a silly song that subtly (and humorously) expressed his displeasure at not being heard.

Fast forward 30 years, and I’m the one trying to talk over three squealing girls as they dash through the living room hooked together by a string of leggings while my boys turn the toy bin over with a spectacular crash followed by vrooming, honking and hooting sounds. (That is an exact scenario). And guess what? I totally get what he was singing about.

“Sami!” I call. “It’s your turn to set the table! Will you come set the table?”

She gallops through the kitchen, laughing.

“Eliza! I’ve asked you three times to hang up your coat. Will you please hang up your coat?”

She trundles down the stairs.

“Speeeeeencer, Gorrrrrrrrdon! It’s time for dinner! Will you please come get in your chairs?”

No time for dinner. No awareness of Mom. No recognition that my voice was just left dangling in the air, useless.

After asking politely, begging a bit, then raising my voice a few decibels, the blood beneath my eyebrows starts to boil, the steam inside my ears starts rising, and pretty soon I feel like a kettle ready to blow.

Then I think of my Dad’s song. And out it comes. Right off my lips like it’s always been there.

“I talk to the treeeeeees … but they don’t listen to me.”

Instead of yelling, I start to laugh. Because it is kind of funny. That’s what they are sometimes. Trees. All five of them. And they’re not listening to me at all!

So what to do?

Sometimes yelling slows the action, stops a certain behavior. But it comes at a price. A child’s feelings get hurt, I feel guilty because I didn’t keep my cool, and there’s always the emotional clean-up afterwards.

For years Freudian philosophy said it was cathartic to vent your anger — go ahead, let it out, blow off that steam. Recently, however, that idea is being replaced by scores of studies that show venting doesn’t actually soothe anger; it fuels it [1]. I have learned all of us are better off I don’t go to my angry place.

When we’re finally gathered around the table, I tell them the story about my dad.

They get a kick out of it.

I tell them I don’t want to talk to trees. I want to talk to kids who can hear me. And you know what? They listened.

I’ve taken to singing my Dad’s song fairly often. When I do, my kids understand they should be listening. And it’s kind of magical. They come to the table, hang up their coats and  get napkins from the pantry. Not always. (No system is perfect.) But if nothing else, it redirects my own emotion, helps me walk more peaceably, and reminds me that my kids won’t always be this crazy, our home this chaotic.

My dad knew something I occasionally forget. That the insanity known as horse and buggy with leggings, dinos that hoot, cars that crash, and giggles that cannot be contained will end. All too soon there will be no din to shout over. No herd of toddlers to corral. Gone will be the innocent creativity of small children, the playfulness they prioritize, the tiny bodies held on my hip, the leg hugs and the sticky hands that slip so easily into mine.

Why screech and rant? This season is brief, the apron strings already beginning to slip. Maybe there’s something worth laughing at with my children? A child that would feel loved if I stopped for a minute and put my arm around her to gently request her help. Surely a little more patience, combined with a sense of humor, would give me more mileage than that stormy, put-out look.

So I make eye-contact with the child that needs to listen; I kneel down to talk to him or her — nose to nose. I speak calmly but directly, and then I smile. It feels good to hold it together, be the eye in the storm.

Isn’t the best teaching always done by example?

“Teach your children everything you know, and, when you must, use words.”

I also love this from Plato.

“With anything young and tender the most important part of the task is the beginning of it; for that is the time at which the character is being formed and the desired impression more readily taken.”

Trees grow in every house. So in case you’re musically inclined, I jotted down the tune for you.

But any tune will do.

[1] Cain, Susan (2012). Quiet: The Power of Introverts in a World That Can’t Stop Talking pg. 233. CROWN Random House, Inc.


  1. Lori

    The song is from Paint Your Wagon. My mom used to put on her walkman with that tape in it and sing – loudly – while she exercised 🙂
    I feel the same about my own sometimes … “I talk to the stars but they never hear me. The breeze hasn’t time to stop and hear what I say; I talk to them all in vain.” Luckily, in the song someone does end up listening . As my children get older we have had great conversations – and sometimes they even think I know what I’m talking about! I guess my wisdom comes later.

    • Catherine A.

      Lori – My father is out of town, so his brother came to the rescue to inform me (after this ran on the DN site) as you did, that the song is from Paint Your Wagon. Thank you for your wonderful comment. I then listened to Clint Eastwood’s version and thought the rest of the lyrics were equally apt. I look forward to those days of deeper conversations you speak of. 😉 Thanks for the laugh and your insights.

Leave a comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.